Italy plunge England into crisis with landmark win
· Yahoo Sports
Italy (10) 23
Tries: Menoncello, Marin Cons: P Garbisi 2 Pens: P Garbisi (3)
Visit asg-reflektory.pl for more information.
England (12) 18
Tries: Freeman, Roebuck Cons: F Smith Pens: F Smith (2)
England's Six Nations campaign plunged deeper into crisis as second-half yellow cards for Sam Underhill and Maro Itoje paved the way to victory for a joyous Italy in Rome.
It is a third successive Six Nations defeat for England and Italy's first-ever win in the fixture after 32 unsuccessful attempts.
For head coach Steve Borthwick another uninspired and insipid performance, 18 months out from the Rugby World Cup, raises the most awkward and far-reaching questions.
England will go to their final-day meeting with France next week, earmarked as a possible Grand Slam decider at the start of the tournament, as minor characters attempting to somehow avoid their first single-win campaign in Six Nations history.
While England had made heavy weather of building a lead, they seemed well insulated against such a seismic shock with an 18-10 advantage and a little more than 20 minutes left.
However, Underhill was dispatched to the sin-bin for a high hit on Northampton's Danilo Fischetti before captain Itoje followed for mindlessly slapping the ball out of Italy scrum-half Alessandro Garbisi's hands.
England lost two players for 10 minutes and Italy gained momentum for the rest of the match, delivering the decisive blow eight minutes from time as Paolo Garbisi, Monty Ioane and Tomasso Menoncello combined thrillingly to put Leonardo Marin in under the posts.
At the final whistle, England's players stood around stunned as the disco lights and celebrations erupted around them. Italy had claimed history - England look to an uncertain future.
New-look line-up, same old problems
Itoje was shown his second yellow card of a Six Nations campaign in which England's discipline has been well below par [Getty Images]England had vowed that, after lifeless defeats by Scotland and Ireland in the previous two rounds, Rome would be a return to the intensity and intent that marked a successful 2025.
Their afternoon got off to a bad start before the first whistle.
An injury to flanker Tom Curry forced England to make further changes to a line-up that had already been radically rejigged.
Underhill was promoted off the bench and into back row alongside Guy Pepper and Ben Earl, with Chandler Cunningham-South added to the replacements.
Their new-look side ran into painfully familiar problems however.
Against Ireland a fortnight ago, England made 16 visits to the opposition 22, but returned with a relatively paltry 21 points.
Once again, they had plenty of ball and possession, but precious little penetration through the opposition defence.
Italy's eager back row soaked up England's ponderous forward rumbles and when the ball went wide, their defensive shape was barely ruffled.
England's efforts were undercut by a string of errors. Fin Smith was charged down with relative ease by number eight Lorenzo Cannone, Alex Coles and Joe Heyes combined to spill line-out ball and Guy Pepper was bowled into touch as he attempted to make metres out wide, all inside the first 15 minutes.
In the build-up to the match, Borthwick had urged his side to chance their arm and throw one more pass. But Italy looked quicker witted and more ambitious throughout.
A pair of clever kicks from fly-half Paolo Garbisi - the second, a well-weighted sideways nudge to release Ioane - set up the field position from which the fly-half kicked the first points of the match on 21 minutes.
An accurate long line-out throw and an Earl rumble gave England the momentum to put Tommy Freeman in for his ninth Test try, although Smith pushed the kickable conversion wide and Italy lurked dangerously as England continued to splutter.
Five minutes before the break, Menoncello - Italy's leading metre-maker, clean-breaker and defender-beater so far in the championship - made good on the threat.
The 23-year-old carved past a startled Heyes on the fringe of a breakdown and galloped over to put Italy 10-5 in front.
England recovered. Albeit briefly.
A smart kick from Smith switched play to Tom Roebuck, and the Sale wing showed deft footwork to scamper in on the stroke of half-time.
A pair of Smith penalties after the break stretched England's lead out to 18-10 and England seemed to be turning the tide of the contest, with Underhill and Itoje both burrowing deep for turnovers.
However, with 25 minutes to go and the match seemingly there for the taking, England's contrived to hand the initiative back to Italy.
Underhill and Itoje watched on grimly from the sidelines as first Garbisi's boot and then their backline's all-court brilliance - Ioane stepping Roebuck in a sliver of space, Menoncello bullocking on and Marin gleefully scampering in - wrenched the contest out of their grasp.
England found some late urgency as they vainly chased the game. Ollie Chessum bust a hole to spin the Italian defence, but the scramble snuffed out the danger.
England looked dazed and at the end of days, as the clock went red, the ball went dead and the Stadio Olimpico lit up and leapt to its feet around them.
Defeat by France in Paris next weekend would mark only the third time in the 115-year history of the Five and Six Nations that England have lost four games in a single campaign.